Executive Summary

Though Splunk and ELK offer similar features, choosing the ideal solution for a specific enterprise depends heavily on the use-case being contemplated and the organization’s capacity to integrate and build on top of technology platforms.

Splunk offers robust commercial level support and a broader set of plugins/apps than ELK. These offerings can lower the effort required to integrate Splunk into an enterprise and use it across a broad set of use-cases. For organizations with narrower requirements, ELK offers a compelling solution, with support for numerous data sources with standard plugins and apps. ELK’s open source nature allows teams capable of developing plugin code to build an excellent customized solution on the ELK platform.

In this paper, we evaluate Splunk and Elastic (ELK) along criteria that are relevant to medium and large-scale organizations. These include ease of adoption, integration into a heterogenous compute environment, scalability, support for public cloud infrastructure monitoring, performance, total cost of ownership, and features relevant to use cases of value for our clients.

Read our other Splunk piece, relevant to the build for large-scale environments. Read More →

Contents

– Why aggregate logs?
– Executive Summary
– Feature Set Comparison
– Ingestion/Integration Add-Ons/Adapters
– Applications/Pre-built reports
– Performance
– Maintainability and Scaling
– Cloud Offering
– Support
– Ease of Use and Training
– Total Cost of Ownership/Use
– Conclusion

Authors

Subir Grewal

subir.grewal@riskfocus.com

Lloyd Altman

lloyd.altman@riskfocus.com

Cary Dym

cary.dym@riskfocus.com

Peter Meulbroek

peter.meulbroek@riskfocus.com

Tara Ronel

tara.ronel@riskfocus.com

Download the Whitepaper



About Risk Focus

We created Risk Focus in 2004, but our technical and leadership experience goes back much further. Our clients lean on us for our deep domain knowledge, unmatched technology expertise and fine-tuned problem-solving and delivery methodologies.

We have deliberately avoided breakneck growth, instead hiring only proven industry experts and curious, thoughtful technologists who are motivated by the variety and scale of the challenges they conquer in our client projects.